The Marin Board of Supervisors is considering entering into a contract to use an AI system, Peregrine, that can enable local law enforcement to violate the privacy and civil liberties of law-abiding residents without due process. The contract will be considered at an upcoming BOS meeting in September. The specific date is still TBD.
In advance of the meeting where the contract will be considered, Marin residents who oppose this contract should send emails to their Supervisors ASAP. When the date to discuss the contract has been set, we will ask you to send another email to the full Board and to attend the meeting to speak out.
Marin County law enforcement says the proposed the $1.5 million contract with Peregrine will help fight crime. But Peregrine’s artificial intelligence (AI) data integration system is a mass surveillance multiplier - it will chart the day-to-day movements and associations of every law-abiding resident and make that information readily accessible to the government on an easy to use dashboard. Technologies like Peregrine allow police to circumvent due process by gathering, integrating and mining a vast expanse of personal data with no judicial oversight or intervention, no warrants, and no probable cause.
This AI surveillance violates many federal and state laws and principles, with no formal accountability. Similar systems (like Flock) have already been reported to have been abused for unofficial and illegitimate purposes. And the possibility of this being used in conjunction with unwarranted ICE activities in Marin expands those dangers exponentially. To learn more about the proposed Peregrine contract, read this excellent backgrounder from our allied Marin partner, MVFREE.
We need to voice our opposition and demand that the BOS reject the Peregrine contract. At a minimum, the Board must defer its consideration of the contract to allow for a more fully informed and transparent process:
(1) the Board should not approve the contract without hearing from its own Civilian Oversight Commission whose investigation and recommendations on Peregrine are expected by the end of the year; and
(2) the Board should not move forward without an adequate approval process and criteria for new surveillance technologies. Santa Clara County in the Silicon Valley provides a good model.
TAKE ACTION!
1) Find your Supervisor based on your street address
2) Email your Supervisor ASAP
Dist 1: Mary Sackett - Mary.Sackett@marincounty.gov
Dist 2: Brian Colbert - brian.colbert@marincounty.gov
Dist 3: Stephanie Moulton-Peters - Stephanie.MoultonPeters@marincounty.gov
Dist 4: Dennis Rodoni - dennis.rodoni@marincounty.gov
Dist 5: Eric Lucan - eric.lucan@marincounty.gov
3) Optional bullet points for emails to supervisors:
Please reject the Peregrine contract!
Technologies like Peregrine allow police to circumvent due process by gathering, integrating and mining a vast expanse of personal data - 99% of it about law-abiding residents, wholly unrelated to suspected criminal conduct - with no judicial oversight or intervention, no warrants, and no probable cause. This violates many federal and state laws and principles, with no formal accountability.
There is no reason to rush headlong into a contract like this without a deliberate and fully informed, transparent public process.
Please wait at least until the Civilian Oversight Commission completes its investigation and recommendations, expected by the end of the year.
Please do not move forward without a better approval process and criteria for new surveillance technologies than in the current data policy, which is inadequate. You can find a good model in the policy enacted by Santa Clara County, which includes many more detailed safeguards.
This system threatens to enable the violation of privacy and civil liberties of law-abiding residents across the entire county, without constraint. Similar systems (like Flock) have already been reported to have been abused for unofficial and illegitimate purposes. And the possibility of this being used in conjunction with unwarranted ICE activities in Marin expands those dangers exponentially. This is unacceptable and cannot be allowed.
Stay tuned for another email from IndiMarin with the Board meeting date when it is set. It will make a big difference if as many Marin residents as possible participate in that hearing in real time, either in person or by Zoom.
